VWAP Pull-In Quality Gate

Source: VWAP_PULL_IN_SPLIT_DIAGNOSTIC · Sample: 127 plain Pull-In trades (−$364) + 15 Pull-In → Trend trades (+$367) on main.trade_context through 2026-06-03 · Use: pre-trade or live-review filter. Print this. Refer to it before reaching for a VWAP Pull-In setup.
→ Want the short version for live trading?

This page is the full research. For the simple decision card — gate, sizing, post-entry management, “say this out loud,” example cards — open the VWAP Pull-In Actionable Playbook. (Machine spec: vwap_pull_in_actionable_gate.json.)

⚠ Mechanism caveat (added 2026-06-04)

The slug vwap-pull-in -> trend is currently outcome-based, not mechanism-confirmed. It should be read as "profitable Pull-In with wide exit," not automatically as "true trend conversion." First 5-minute post-entry behavior determines management:

See PULL_IN_TO_TREND_MECHANISM_AUDIT for the data behind this caveat.

1. Executive summary

2. VWAP Pull-In Quality Gate

🟢 GREEN — TAKE: RVOL 1.0–1.5 AND gap < 0.5% AND MTF grand > 25 AND not emotionally extended
Normal Pull-In allowed. Still requires execution trigger (LB1 hold + EMA cross / volume confirmation). Hold for trend conversion if price closes above +2 SD — do not auto-exit at +2 SD. This is where PI → Trend lives.
🟡 YELLOW — CAUTION: RVOL 1.5–2.5 OR gap 0.5%–1.5%
Reduced size only. Take ONLY if structure is clean AND you can articulate the trend-conversion thesis BEFORE entry. If you can't, pass.
🔴 RED — STOP: RVOL > 2.5 OR gap > 1.5% OR symbol in {IBIT, AMD, ETHU, RGTI} OR entry < 10:00 ET in hot tape
Do NOT treat as plain Pull-In. Reclassify (see §3) or pass. This is the leak. Plain PI losers cluster here.

3. Setup reclassification rules

When RVOL/gap is hot (🟡/🔴 zone), do NOT call it a plain Pull-In by default. The setup is something else — name it correctly before entering, or pass.

If the tape shows...The real setup is...Different rules apply
Stock making HH+HL after +2 SD close, you're entering on a pullback to +1 SD with VWAP slope risingPull-In → Trend / Trend TradeWider stop (VWAP), bigger target (+4 SD), hold the core
Stock extended >2 SD from VWAP avg with no setup support, momentum chaseChase / ExtendedThis is a behavioral chase tag, NOT an edge. Pass.
Stock at intraday/HTF range edge, volume building toward the edgeRange Break / HitchhikerWait for the break, stop outside the consolidation
Stock extended ≥2.5 SD BELOW VWAP with double-bottom failure formingRubberband / Backside LongBand-anchored stop at −2 SD, full exit at VWAP, no trailing
Cannot honestly name what it is in calm-tape Pull-In termsPass.The setup may not exist on this name today

Rule: if the only honest label is "I want to be in this stock right now," that's not a Pull-In — that's a chase. The taxonomy has a slug for it (chase-extended) and its net P&L is +$200/56 trades = $3.57/trade (basically flat). It is NOT an edge.

4. Practical tomorrow checklist

Before clicking buy on any VWAP Pull-In, answer all seven out loud:

  1. What is RVOL right now? (target: 1.0–1.5; >2.5 = stop)
  2. What is the gap %? (target: <0.5%; >1.5% = stop)
  3. Is this first-hour emotional tape? (09-10 ET with hot RVOL = double-strict filters)
  4. Is price controlled around VWAP, or is it hot expansion? (controlled = OK; expansion = either Pull-In → Trend management or pass)
  5. Is there evidence this can convert to trend? (HH+HL structure, MTF grand > 25, +2 SD reach achievable)
  6. Is this really a plain Pull-In, or am I chasing an extended move? (if you hesitate on the answer, you're chasing)
  7. If it fails to convert, where do I exit? (LB1 / VWAP / time stop — pick one BEFORE entry)

If you can't answer 1–7 quickly, the trade isn't ready. Pass.

5. Post-entry management rule (mechanism-aware)

Once you're in a Pull-In, the FIRST 5 MINUTES tell you which mechanism you're actually in. Manage accordingly:

This is mechanism-aware management. The slug name describes the OUTCOME after the trade closes; the trajectory in the first 5 minutes is what tells you in real time how to manage it.

6. Risk rule candidates (research, not final hard rules)

These are research candidates from the diagnostic data. Validate against the next 2 weeks of live trades before locking in.

CandidateEstimated effect
R1. Skip plain Pull-In if RVOL > 2.5Excludes ~50–60 trades, recovers ~+$300
R2. Skip plain Pull-In if gap > 1.5%Excludes the +2% gap-up hyped names
R3. Combined hot-tape filter: skip if (RVOL > 2 AND gap > 1%) OR RVOL > 3 OR gap > 2%Strongest combined — recovers ~+$400
R4. Flag IBIT, AMD, ETHU, RGTI for sample review before any more plain Pull-Ins (consider blacklist OR require stricter R1 = RVOL < 1.5)Recovers ~+$100 incrementally
R5. First-hour strictness: 09:00–10:00 ET requires R1+R2 in stricter form (RVOL < 2, gap < 1%)Tightens the worst-performing hour
R6. In calm tape (R1 GREEN), default to managing for Pull-In → Trend conversion — do not scratch at +1.5 SD; hold for +2 SD close or VWAP-based stopCaptures the conversion edge currently under-fired (15/142)

Combined R1+R2+R4 estimated P&L delta on the historical sample: +$500 swing in vwap_pullback_continuation family (from +$3 net to ~+$500 net).

7. What VCET should test next

HypothesisWhat we'd expect to see
PI → Trend winners occur during EARLY_EXPANSION → EXPANSION_CONFIRMED → TREND_UP/DOWN≥70% of PI→Trend wins should land in those 3 states at entry; <30% in ROTATION
Plain PI losers occur during ROTATION, FAILED_EXPANSION_TENTATIVE/CONFIRMED, weak compression, or MEAN_REVERSION against the tradeConcentration in regimes where the engine says "no directional commitment yet"
VWAP-band expansion + slope + range-break confirmation separate converters from non-convertersvwap_band_width and vwap_slope at entry should be higher (band fan + slope rising) on PI→Trend wins than on plain PI losses
CBO range-break (v1.1) refines the conversion callOnce CBO lands, EXPANSION_CONFIRMED + CBO confirmed should produce near-100% PI→Trend hit rate

If these hypotheses hold, VCET state becomes the state filter the gate above approximates with RVOL+gap. Until then, RVOL+gap is the best available proxy.

8. The one-sentence rule

"Plain VWAP Pull-In is only a clean setup in calm, controlled tape; in hot tape, it must either be managed for trend conversion or be passed."

Glossary

Links