Only 1 of 5 is a true ROTATION → TREND conversion. The other 4 split into:
| # | Trade | P&L | Conversion? | What it really was |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | DAL 5/26 13:56 | +$68.25 | ❌ NO | TD VWAP rotation scalp (stayed ROTATION, slope ≈ 0, compression building) |
| 2 | DAL 5/27 13:56 | +$22.50 | ❌ NO | Counter-trend buy on big gap-down (−5.4%); stayed ROTATION; slope negative |
| 3 | JOBY 5/28 09:31 | +$12.45 | ✅ YES | True ROTATION → TREND_UP at +15min; bw 1.54 → 6.42, slope +1.6° → +49° |
| 4 | DAL 5/28 13:56 | +$5.59 | ❌ NO | Tight compression, score climbing (96 → 100), modest +$0.08 drift |
| 5 | JOBY 5/29 09:31 | +$0.70 | ❌ NO (wrong side!) | LONG into TREND_DOWN crash; slope −3.9° → −66.9°; barely escaped scratch |
So the "5 ROTATION winners" framing from the pilot was misleading. The real read: 1 confirmed conversion, 3 mislabeled rotation scalps, 1 lucky escape.
RVOL 0.73 (calm) · Gap −1.3% · ATR −0.39 · MTF 83 (strong) · no catalyst
| t | state | reason | score | slope° | bw% | exp | comp | close |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| −5 | ROTATION | FLAT_BANDS | 60 | −0.39 | 1.49 | 0 | 0 | 78.32 |
| 0 | ROTATION | FLAT_BANDS | 90 | −0.35 | 1.49 | 0 | 0 | 78.42 |
| +5 | ROTATION | FLAT_BANDS | 91 | −0.35 | 1.49 | 15 | 0 | 78.54 |
| +10 | ROTATION | FLAT_BANDS | 93 | −0.34 | 1.49 | 0 | 0 | 78.53 |
| +15 | ROTATION | FLAT_BANDS | 94 | −0.29 | 1.48 | 0 | 0 | 78.50 |
| +25 | ROTATION | FLAT_BANDS | 96 | −0.20 | 1.48 | 0 | 30 | 78.52 |
Verdict: Stayed in ROTATION the whole 25 min. Slope ≈ 0 throughout. Bands barely moved. Score CLIMBED 60 → 96. Price drifted +$0.10/share. Textbook TD VWAP rotation scalp profile. The slug "Pull-In → Trend" is wrong for this trade — it never converted.
RVOL 1.31 · Gap −5.4% (big gap down) · ATR −1.6 (very oversold) · MTF 82 · no catalyst
| t | state | reason | score | slope° | bw% | exp | close |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| −5 | ROTATION | STICKY_DEFAULT | 53 | −1.15 | 2.82 | 35 | 81.73 |
| 0 | ROTATION | STICKY_DEFAULT | 52 | −1.34 | 2.86 | 15 | 81.71 |
| +5 | ROTATION | STICKY_DEFAULT | 50 | −1.63 | 2.92 | 35 | 81.49 |
| +10 | ROTATION | STICKY_DEFAULT | 48 | −1.76 | 2.97 | 15 | 81.46 |
| +15 | ROTATION | STICKY_DEFAULT | 47 | −1.92 | 3.01 | 15 | 81.50 |
| +25 | ROTATION | STICKY_DEFAULT | 45 | −1.40 | 3.05 | 0 | 81.56 |
Verdict: Slope NEGATIVE entire window. Bands EXPANDING slightly. Score DECREASING. Price moved AGAINST the LONG entry (−$0.15). Trade was profitable despite unfavorable trajectory — likely small share count, tight management, or scratched within minutes. Not a conversion.
RVOL 1.59 · Gap +0.74% (calm open) · ATR +0.11 (flat) · MTF 62 · no catalyst
| t | state | reason | score | slope° | bw% | exp | close |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| −5 | ROTATION | SESSION_INACTIVE | 41 | +1.61 | 1.54 | 20 | 11.43 |
| 0 | ROTATION | SESSION_INACTIVE | 0 | +17.99 | 2.98 | 75 | 11.59 |
| +5 | ROTATION | SESSION_INACTIVE | 0 | +31.37 | 5.03 | 75 | 11.76 |
| +10 | ROTATION | SESSION_INACTIVE | 0 | +42.92 | 6.16 | 75 | 11.87 |
| +15 | TREND_UP | SLOPE_STRONG | 100 | +49.06 | 6.42 | 35 | 11.83 |
| +25 | TREND_UP | SLOPE_STRONG | 100 | +44.38 | 6.72 | 20 | 11.98 |
Verdict: THE conversion pattern. Entered with bands narrow (1.54) and slope barely positive (+1.6). Within 5 min: bands DOUBLED, slope EXPLODED, expansion_score jumped 20 → 75. By +15 min: state TREND_UP with score 100. Price moved 11.43 → 11.98 (+4.8%). The compression-before-expansion signature is unmistakable — but NOT visible at entry. Conversion happened in the first 5 minutes AFTER entry.
RVOL 0.94 (calm) · Gap −8.1% (huge gap down) · ATR −2.5 (very oversold) · MTF 74 · no catalyst
| t | state | reason | score | slope° | bw% | exp | comp | close |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| −5 | ROTATION | FLAT_BANDS | 96 | +0.21 | 2.84 | 15 | 30 | 81.97 |
| 0 | ROTATION | FLAT_BANDS | 96 | +0.27 | 2.82 | 35 | 30 | 81.93 |
| +5 | ROTATION | FLAT_BANDS | 97 | +0.20 | 2.81 | 0 | 30 | 81.89 |
| +10 | ROTATION | FLAT_BANDS | 98 | +0.20 | 2.79 | 0 | 30 | 81.95 |
| +15 | ROTATION | FLAT_BANDS | 99 | +0.17 | 2.78 | 0 | 30 | 81.88 |
| +25 | ROTATION | FLAT_BANDS | 100 | +0.11 | 2.75 | 0 | 30 | 82.01 |
Verdict: Slope very close to zero. Bands CONTRACTING. Compression_score = 30 the entire time — true compression. Score climbed 96 → 100. Price drift +$0.08. Compression scalp — tight, low-vol, modest gain. Compression NEVER resolved into expansion within 25 min. Not a Pull-In → Trend conversion.
RVOL 1.76 · Gap −5.6% (big gap down) · ATR −0.88 · MTF 22 (weak) · no catalyst
| t | state | reason | score | slope° | bw% | exp | close |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| −5 | ROTATION | SESSION_INACTIVE | 0 | −3.94 | 2.05 | 75 | 12.12 |
| 0 | ROTATION | SESSION_INACTIVE | 0 | −36.59 | 5.54 | 75 | 11.92 |
| +5 | TREND_DOWN | SLOPE_STRONG | 100 | −52.74 | 7.02 | 75 | 11.73 |
| +10 | TREND_DOWN | SLOPE_STRONG | 100 | −62.22 | 7.59 | 35 | 11.74 |
| +15 | TREND_DOWN | STICKY_DEFAULT | 70 | −66.91 | 7.51 | 35 | 11.77 |
| +25 | TREND_DOWN | STICKY_DEFAULT | 64 | −37.09 | 7.24 | 20 | 11.78 |
Verdict: Slope already −3.94° at −5min. Within 5 min after entry: slope −52.7°, bands wide open (7.02), state TREND_DOWN. VCET correctly identified the down-direction trend within 5 minutes. The LONG trade was wrong-side. Price fell 11.92 → 11.73 (−1.6%) in first 5 minutes after entry. The +$0.70 P&L was either a tiny share count, scratched immediately, or saved by late drift back. Not a successful conversion — a tape lucky to break even.
Mostly NO. Only 1 of 5 (JOBY 5/28) showed compression-before-expansion: narrow bands at entry (1.54) → rapid expansion (1.54 → 6.42 in 15 min) → state transition ROTATION → TREND_UP at +15min.
The other 4: 3 DAL trades had bands stay flat, slope stay ≈ 0, no expansion ever fired (genuine rotation scalps, classifier mislabeled them). 1 JOBY 5/29 had bands expand DOWNWARD into TREND_DOWN — wrong direction for a LONG.
YES — definitively. JOBY 5/28 is the proof: state at entry was ROTATION (SESSION_INACTIVE); state at +15 min was TREND_UP (SLOPE_STRONG). A state-at-entry filter would have flagged it as "rotation, pass" or "no fresh signal." The conversion was visible only in the trajectory — band width DOUBLING in 5 min, slope going from +1.6° to +17.99° to +31.37°, expansion_score jumping 20 → 75 in 5 min.
The numeric DERIVATIVES (rate of change of slope, rate of band expansion) distinguish a real conversion from a rotation scalp. State labels are too lagging.
YES. Track: band-width delta at +5min, slope acceleration entry-5 → entry+5, expansion_score climbing past 50 within 10 min, state transition into EARLY_EXPANSION / EXPANSION_CONFIRMED within 15 min.
Caveat: the gen_scorecard.py classifier's labeling of "Pull-In → Trend" appears inconsistent with this signature. Of 5 trades it labeled PI→Trend ROTATION winners, only 1 actually showed the conversion. The classifier may be tagging trades on outcome, not on the conversion mechanism — a taxonomy refinement question for later.
YES with specific thresholds from this review:
| Numeric | Pre-trade prefer | Pre-trade avoid |
|---|---|---|
vwap_band_width_pct at entry | < 2.0 (narrow = compression possible) | > 6.0 (already-expanded = past the move) |
vwap_slope_deg at entry | Watch sign — POSITIVE for LONG | Strongly NEGATIVE for LONG |
vcet_score at entry | > 55 | < 30 (often SESSION_INACTIVE / low-conviction) |
range_compression_score at entry | > 25 (compression building) | < 5 (no compression structure) |
Secondary filter, not replacement. RVOL + gap caught the Pull-In split cleanly on the full 127-trade sample. VCET numerics add another layer of CONTEXT but don't displace the primary filter.
vwap-pull-in -> trend is unreliableFrom this 5-trade sample, only 1 (JOBY 5/28) was a true conversion. The other 4 were mislabeled — they didn't trade through a state transition; they were rotation/compression scalps that profited.
Implication: the +$367 cumulative P&L credited to vwap-pull-in -> trend is real, but the slug name overstates the conversion mechanism. Some of those wins were rotation scalps that happened to exit at +2 SD.
This is NOT a taxonomy problem — the canonical slug system is fine. It's a classifier accuracy problem in gen_scorecard.py. The fix would be to re-define Priority 3 to require a state transition (VCET data at entry → exit), not just a wide exit. Phase 5+ scope.
main.vcet_bars yet — strengthens the pilot's verdict that v1.0 entry-state isn't the right layer. Trajectory analysis with v1.1 + CBO would be the proper next investment.gen_scorecard.py patches (classifier accuracy concern flagged, not fixed)Phase board unchanged.