vwap-pull-in -> trend is currently outcome-based, not mechanism-confirmed. Read it as "profitable Pull-In with wide exit," NOT automatically as "true trend conversion." First 5-minute post-entry behavior determines management: expansion + slope acceleration = possible trend conversion; flat band + flat slope = rotation scalp; opposite state/slope = wrong-side escape. (audit)
|
🟢 GREEN — TAKE
RVOL 1.0–1.5 AND gap < 0.5% AND MTF grand > 25
Normal Pull-In allowed. Hold for trend conversion at +2 SD — do NOT scratch at +1 SD.
|
🟡 YELLOW — CAUTION
RVOL 1.5–2.5 OR gap 0.5–1.5%
Reduced size only. Take ONLY if structure is clean AND you can articulate the trend-conversion thesis BEFORE entry.
|
🔴 RED — STOP
RVOL > 2.5 OR gap > 1.5% OR symbol in {IBIT, AMD, ETHU, RGTI} OR entry < 10:00 ET in hot tape
Do NOT treat as plain Pull-In. Reclassify (see below) or pass.
|
Before clicking buy, answer all 7 out loud:
If you can't answer 1–7 quickly: pass.
| What the tape shows | Real setup name | Different rules |
|---|---|---|
| HH+HL after +2 SD close; entering on pullback to +1 SD; VWAP slope rising | Pull-In → Trend / Trend Trade | Stop = VWAP, target = +4 SD, hold the core |
| Extended >2 SD from VWAP avg, no setup, momentum chase | Chase / Extended | NOT an edge (net flat). Pass. |
| At intraday/HTF range edge, volume building toward edge | Range Break / Hitchhiker | Wait for the break, stop outside the consolidation |
| Extended ≥2.5 SD BELOW VWAP, double-bottom failure forming | Rubberband / Backside Long | Stop = −2 SD band, exit at VWAP, no trailing |
| Can't honestly name it in calm-tape Pull-In terms | Pass. | The setup doesn't exist on this name today |
Rule of thumb: if the only honest label is "I want to be in this stock right now" — that's a chase, not a Pull-In. Pass.
Once in the trade, the first 5 minutes reveal the actual mechanism. Manage to what the tape is doing, not to the slug name:
vwap-pull-in -> trend. That label is post-hoc; it doesn't validate the management decision you made at minute 5.These 4 symbols carried −$360 of the −$364 total plain Pull-In loss over the sample window. Treat as RED tape by default; require RVOL <1.5 AND gap <0.5% AND clean conversion thesis before plain Pull-In.
09:00–10:00 ET held 91 of 127 plain Pull-In trades and −$401 of P&L in the sample window. Same hour, PI → Trend was +$253 at 100% win rate (n=11). The hour isn't the problem; selection within the hour is. In this window, apply Rule R5: require RVOL <2 AND gap <1%. Otherwise pass.