VCET v0.1.2 Expansion-Gate Timing Study

Diagnostic / research-only · v0.1.1 ruleset locked · No production v0.1.2 created. Spec: Z:\trading\dev\vcet-replay-viewer\vcet_ruleset_v0_1_2_research_candidates.json
⚠️ ruleset_design_sample — Sample reused from classifier debug. NOT clean OOS. Any candidate improvement here is hypothesis generation, not validation.

Canonical 2-minute cases

Each row is a raw CBO event detected by the engine. Columns show how each candidate rule handles it.

SMCI 2026-06-11 2-min

Canonical compression-break case (visual replay reference) · Raw CBOs: 20

timesideclosechan_hichan_lodistσ labelv0.1.1reject Cand ACand B rawCand B confirmCand C role
09:18 short 28.50 29.45 28.51 -2.26 chase_risk ✗ REJECTED vwap_width_expanding=False no RAW cbo_chase_risk
09:30 long 30.05 29.60 28.44 +2.02 chase_risk ✓ QUALIFIED no RAW +1✓ cbo_chase_risk
10:12 short 28.78 30.12 28.83 -1.63 unclassified ✗ REJECTED prior_state=TREND_UP_not_in_allowed; vwap_width_expanding=False no no raw_cbo_break
12:18 long 29.47 29.44 29.08 +0.62 compression_break ✗ REJECTED vwap_width_expanding=False YES RAW qualified_compression_break_entry
12:24 long 29.68 29.52 29.08 +1.35 compression_break ✗ REJECTED vwap_width_expanding=False no RAW raw_cbo_break
12:36 long 29.84 29.83 29.08 +1.83 trend_continuation_confirm ✗ REJECTED vwap_width_expanding=False no RAW cbo_confirmation
13:00 long 30.24 30.21 29.38 +2.71 late_extension_break ✗ REJECTED vwap_width_expanding=False no RAW cbo_confirmation
13:02 long 30.27 30.25 29.39 +2.71 late_extension_break ✗ REJECTED vwap_width_expanding=False no RAW cbo_confirmation
13:04 long 30.34 30.32 29.44 +2.86 late_extension_break ✗ REJECTED vwap_width_expanding=False no RAW cbo_confirmation
13:06 long 30.47 30.35 29.58 +3.16 late_extension_break ✗ REJECTED vwap_width_expanding=False no RAW cbo_confirmation
14:24 long 30.71 30.65 30.14 +2.59 late_extension_break ✗ REJECTED prior_state=MEAN_REVERSION_not_in_allowed; vwap_width_expanding=False no no cbo_confirmation
14:26 long 30.79 30.73 30.14 +2.70 late_extension_break ✗ REJECTED prior_state=MEAN_REVERSION_not_in_allowed; vwap_width_expanding=False no no cbo_confirmation
14:30 long 30.84 30.81 30.14 +2.73 late_extension_break ✗ REJECTED prior_state=MEAN_REVERSION_not_in_allowed; vwap_width_expanding=False no no cbo_confirmation
14:56 long 30.98 30.95 30.37 +2.61 late_extension_break ✗ REJECTED prior_state=MEAN_REVERSION_not_in_allowed; vwap_width_expanding=False no no cbo_confirmation
15:28 long 31.05 31.00 30.76 +2.36 late_extension_break ✗ REJECTED prior_state=MEAN_REVERSION_not_in_allowed; vwap_width_expanding=False no no cbo_confirmation
15:30 long 31.39 31.10 30.76 +2.85 late_extension_break ✗ REJECTED prior_state=MEAN_REVERSION_not_in_allowed; vwap_width_expanding=False no no cbo_confirmation
15:32 long 31.46 31.45 30.76 +2.89 late_extension_break ✗ REJECTED prior_state=MEAN_REVERSION_not_in_allowed; vwap_width_expanding=False no no cbo_confirmation
15:34 long 31.58 31.50 30.76 +2.98 late_extension_break ✗ REJECTED prior_state=MEAN_REVERSION_not_in_allowed; vwap_width_expanding=False no no cbo_confirmation
15:40 long 31.82 31.66 30.76 +3.05 late_extension_break ✗ REJECTED prior_state=MEAN_REVERSION_not_in_allowed; vwap_width_expanding=False no no cbo_confirmation
15:44 long 31.93 31.91 30.76 +2.97 late_extension_break ✗ REJECTED prior_state=MEAN_REVERSION_not_in_allowed; vwap_width_expanding=False no no cbo_confirmation

NVDA 2026-06-15 2-min

Canonical late/chase case · Raw CBOs: 26

timesideclosechan_hichan_lodistσ labelv0.1.1reject Cand ACand B rawCand B confirmCand C role
09:10 long 208.35 208.28 207.70 +0.63 unclassified ✗ REJECTED vwap_width_expanding=False no RAW raw_cbo_break
09:24 long 208.99 208.60 207.70 +2.26 chase_risk ✗ REJECTED vwap_width_expanding=False no RAW +3✓ cbo_chase_risk
09:30 long 210.36 209.10 207.78 +1.39 trend_continuation_confirm ✓ QUALIFIED no RAW +1✓ cbo_confirmation
10:32 long 209.99 209.97 208.33 +0.95 unclassified ✗ REJECTED vwap_width_expanding=False no RAW raw_cbo_break
10:56 long 210.19 210.10 208.58 +1.27 compression_break ✗ REJECTED vwap_width_expanding=False no RAW raw_cbo_break
10:58 long 210.37 210.25 208.58 +1.56 compression_break ✗ REJECTED vwap_width_expanding=False no RAW raw_cbo_break
11:00 long 210.84 210.45 208.58 +2.28 compression_break ✗ REJECTED vwap_width_expanding=False no RAW raw_cbo_break
11:04 long 211.23 210.93 208.58 +2.63 compression_break ✗ REJECTED vwap_width_expanding=False no RAW raw_cbo_break
11:14 long 211.33 211.30 209.23 +2.27 chase_risk ✗ REJECTED vwap_width_expanding=False no RAW cbo_chase_risk
11:36 long 211.61 211.39 209.83 +2.11 late_extension_break ✗ REJECTED vwap_width_expanding=False no RAW cbo_confirmation
11:38 long 211.70 211.61 210.08 +2.14 late_extension_break ✗ REJECTED vwap_width_expanding=False no RAW cbo_confirmation
11:44 long 212.03 211.91 210.58 +2.31 late_extension_break ✗ REJECTED vwap_width_expanding=False no RAW cbo_confirmation
11:46 long 212.21 212.05 210.58 +2.41 late_extension_break ✗ REJECTED vwap_width_expanding=False no RAW cbo_confirmation
11:48 long 212.40 212.24 210.58 +2.48 late_extension_break ✗ REJECTED vwap_width_expanding=False no RAW cbo_confirmation
11:50 long 212.58 212.49 210.58 +2.52 late_extension_break ✗ REJECTED vwap_width_expanding=False no RAW cbo_confirmation
12:44 short 211.94 212.61 211.97 +1.24 late_extension_break ✗ REJECTED vwap_width_expanding=False no RAW cbo_confirmation
13:20 long 212.66 212.45 211.84 +1.66 trend_continuation_confirm ✗ REJECTED vwap_width_expanding=False no RAW cbo_confirmation
13:56 short 211.99 212.68 212.03 +1.03 late_extension_break ✗ REJECTED vwap_width_expanding=False no RAW cbo_confirmation
13:58 short 211.82 212.68 211.86 +0.90 unclassified ✗ REJECTED vwap_width_expanding=False no RAW raw_cbo_break
14:00 short 211.72 212.68 211.80 +0.82 unclassified ✗ REJECTED vwap_width_expanding=False no RAW raw_cbo_break
14:02 short 211.55 212.67 211.71 +0.69 unclassified ✗ REJECTED vwap_width_expanding=False no RAW raw_cbo_break
14:44 long 212.39 212.31 211.42 +1.24 trend_continuation_confirm ✗ REJECTED vwap_width_expanding=False no RAW cbo_confirmation
14:52 long 212.49 212.47 211.79 +1.30 trend_continuation_confirm ✗ REJECTED vwap_width_expanding=False no RAW cbo_confirmation
14:54 long 212.51 212.50 211.79 +1.30 trend_continuation_confirm ✗ REJECTED vwap_width_expanding=False no RAW cbo_confirmation
15:34 short 211.36 212.57 211.59 +0.38 unclassified ✗ REJECTED vwap_width_expanding=False no RAW raw_cbo_break
15:54 long 212.25 212.13 211.00 +1.03 trend_continuation_confirm ✗ REJECTED vwap_width_expanding=False; late_in_session=True no no cbo_confirmation

SPCX 2026-06-12 2-min

Mixed/expansion-failure case · Raw CBOs: 14

timesideclosechan_hichan_lodistσ labelv0.1.1reject Cand ACand B rawCand B confirmCand C role
12:38 long 168.00 167.80 155.20 +1.90 trend_continuation_confirm ✗ REJECTED prior_state=TREND_UP_not_in_allowed; vwap_width_expanding=False no no cbo_confirmation
12:48 long 168.74 168.48 160.50 +1.88 trend_continuation_confirm ✗ REJECTED prior_state=TREND_UP_not_in_allowed; vwap_width_expanding=False no no cbo_confirmation
12:50 long 169.82 169.00 161.00 +2.09 late_extension_break ✗ REJECTED prior_state=TREND_UP_not_in_allowed; vwap_width_expanding=False no no cbo_confirmation
12:52 long 172.49 169.85 161.00 +2.49 late_extension_break ✗ REJECTED prior_state=TREND_UP_not_in_allowed; vwap_width_expanding=False no no cbo_confirmation
12:58 long 173.75 172.90 161.00 +2.52 late_extension_break ✗ REJECTED prior_state=TREND_UP_not_in_allowed; vwap_width_expanding=False no no cbo_confirmation
13:04 long 174.91 174.26 163.07 +2.48 late_extension_break ✗ REJECTED prior_state=TREND_UP_not_in_allowed; vwap_width_expanding=False no no cbo_confirmation
13:06 long 175.18 175.00 163.07 +2.41 late_extension_break ✗ REJECTED prior_state=TREND_UP_not_in_allowed; vwap_width_expanding=False no no cbo_confirmation
13:08 long 176.32 175.50 163.07 +2.52 late_extension_break ✗ REJECTED prior_state=TREND_UP_not_in_allowed; vwap_width_expanding=False no no cbo_confirmation
14:14 short 168.08 174.02 168.90 +0.64 unclassified ✗ REJECTED prior_state=TREND_UP_not_in_allowed; vwap_width_expanding=False no no raw_cbo_break
15:02 short 166.09 171.00 166.30 +0.25 unclassified ✗ REJECTED vwap_width_expanding=False no RAW raw_cbo_break
15:28 short 161.44 170.80 161.56 -0.55 unclassified ✗ REJECTED vwap_width_expanding=False no RAW raw_cbo_break
15:30 short 160.54 170.80 161.31 -0.70 unclassified ✗ REJECTED vwap_width_expanding=False no RAW raw_cbo_break
16:10 long 163.78 162.78 157.43 -0.07 unclassified ✗ REJECTED vwap_width_expanding=False no RAW raw_cbo_break
16:16 long 164.06 164.00 157.43 -0.02 unclassified ✗ REJECTED vwap_width_expanding=False no RAW raw_cbo_break

Cohort summary (6-symbol × 10 days, 5-min)

Raw CBO events evaluated under each variant.

variantNSet A netavg/trwin% Set B netavg/trwin%
v0.1.1 (baseline) 62 +$2,271 +$36.63 45.2% +$1,851 +$29.85 37.1%
Candidate A (compression override)n/a
Candidate B (raw + late confirm) 270 +$8,526 +$31.58 44.8% +$3,107 +$11.51 39.6%
Candidate B (confirmed within 1 bar) 63 +$2,072 +$32.90 44.4% +$1,660 +$26.34 36.5%
Candidate B (confirmed within 2 bars) 65 +$1,681 +$25.86 43.1% +$1,265 +$19.46 35.4%
Candidate B (confirmed within 3 bars) 68 +$2,631 +$38.69 42.6% +$2,937 +$43.19 35.3%

Candidate C role breakdown

P&L for each Candidate C role assignment, using raw-break entry timing.

roleNSet A netavgwin%Set B netavg
cbo_chase_risk 118 +$2,542 +$41.68 47.5% +$782 +$12.81
raw_cbo_break 159 +$3,297 +$33.64 39.8% +$3,499 +$35.71
cbo_confirmation 313 +$2,687 +$24.20 47.7% −$1,174 −$10.58

CBO context label breakdown (cohort)

P&L for each context label, raw-break entry timing.

labelNSet A netavgwin%Set B netavg
chase_risk 118 +$2,542 +$41.68 47.5% +$782 +$12.81
unclassified 153 +$3,143 +$34.16 38.0% +$3,346 +$36.37
trend_continuation_confirm 243 +$341 +$4.16 50.0% −$2,214 −$27.00
late_extension_break 70 +$2,346 +$80.89 41.4% +$1,040 +$35.85
compression_break 6 +$154 +$25.67 66.7% +$153 +$25.58

Why this is not validation yet

Decision output (provisional, based on this sample only)

  1. Is v0.1.1 same-bar expansion gate too strict? Yes on this sample — SMCI 6/11 canonical case and the cohort scan both show the gate rejects raw compression-break events.
  2. Does Candidate A correctly admit SMCI-like compression breaks without admitting NVDA chase-risk? Yes on this sample — Candidate A qualifies SMCI 12:24 (compression_break label + recent compression + near VWAP), rejects NVDA 6/15 (label != compression_break, dist too far).
  3. Does Candidate B solve timing more honestly? Partially — separates raw-break time from confirmation time, but the "confirmed within N" flag uses future bars to label entries that were taken at raw time. The variant_b_confirmed entry timing (enter only after expansion arrives) is the more honest comparison.
  4. Does Candidate C produce the cleanest architecture? Yes for downstream handling — explicit roles let scorecards / forward-test / Param Surface route signals differently. Costs a v0.1.2 schema change.
  5. Which candidate should become v0.1.2_research for the next clean validation sample? Candidate A + Candidate C labels (A for entry qualification, C for downstream role routing). Candidate B as instrumentation only (track confirmation timing for analysis, not as entry rule).
  6. What fresh validation sample should be used next? First option: forward-paper accumulation starting now. Second option: Liberator expanded history when entitlement restored. Either way: must not include any date or symbol from the classifier-debug pipeline.