Sentiment Accuracy — MGP + Multi-TF Stack vs SPY Close

Do our own market calls (MGP morning verdict + MTF regime tag) actually predict which way the tape goes?
The question: when we say RISK OFF or BEARISH in the morning, does the market actually close down? When we say RISK ON or BULLISH, does it close up? Or are we just describing yesterday?
The sample: 52 MGP morning verdicts + 33 MTF daily reads. Both compared against SPY close vs prior close, and open→close intraday.

MGP MORNING — Hit Rates vs Base Rate

BULLISH → UP (n=16)
25%
up:4 dn:6 fl:6
base rate 35% · edge -10 pts
BEARISH → DOWN
n=0
CAUTIOUS → FLAT (n=36)
31%
up:14 dn:11 fl:11
base rate 33% · edge -2 pts
Compared to the market's own base rate on the same days. +edge = real predictive value. −edge = worse than a coin flip.
NOTE: MGP morning has NEVER printed BEARISH — the tape-read only turns red intraday (midday/recap). The morning call is always BULLISH or CAUTIOUS.

Base rate on the days we called something

MGP days (vs prior)
52
UP 35% · DN 33% · FL 33%
MGP days (intraday)
52
UP 29% · DN 31% · FL 40%
MTF days (vs prior)
33
UP 36% · DN 36% · FL 27%

MGP MORNING — Full breakdown

SPY close vs PRIOR close

SentimentUPDOWNFLATTotal
BULLISH4 (25%)6 (38%)616
CAUTIOUS14 (39%)11 (31%)1136

SPY intraday (open → close) — fair-comparison view

SentimentUPDOWNFLATTotal
BULLISH2 (12%)7 (44%)716
CAUTIOUS13 (36%)9 (25%)1436

MTF STACK — Hit Rates vs Base Rate

RISK ON → UP
n=0
LEANING ON → UP (n=1)
100%
up:1 dn:0 fl:0
base rate 36% · edge +64 pts
RISK OFF → DOWN (n=3)
67%
up:1 dn:2 fl:0
base rate 36% · edge +30 pts
LEANING OFF → DOWN (n=17)
41%
up:4 dn:7 fl:6
base rate 36% · edge +5 pts
NEUTRAL → FLAT (n=8)
38%
up:4 dn:1 fl:3
base rate 27% · edge +10 pts

MTF STACK — Full breakdown

SPY close vs PRIOR close

SentimentUPDOWNFLATTotal
LEANING_ON1 (100%)0 (0%)01
NEUTRAL4 (50%)1 (12%)38
LEANING_OFF4 (24%)7 (41%)617
RISK_OFF1 (33%)2 (67%)03
UNKNOWN2 (50%)2 (50%)04

SPY intraday (open → close) — fair-comparison view

SentimentUPDOWNFLATTotal
LEANING_ON1 (100%)0 (0%)01
NEUTRAL1 (12%)3 (38%)48
LEANING_OFF4 (24%)4 (24%)917
RISK_OFF1 (33%)1 (33%)13
UNKNOWN1 (25%)2 (50%)14

Every day, both sources (newest first)

DateSourceRawBucketClose vs Prior % vs prior% intraday
2026-07-31MTFLEANING RISK OFFLEANING_OFFNO_DATA--
2026-07-31MGP_AM#ffab40CAUTIOUSNO_DATA--
2026-07-30MTFLEANING RISK OFFLEANING_OFFUP+1.68%+0.77%
2026-07-30MGP_AM#ffab40CAUTIOUSUP+1.68%+0.77%
2026-07-29MTFLEANING RISK OFFLEANING_OFFDOWN-1.54%-1.42%
2026-07-29MGP_AM#00c853BULLISHDOWN-1.54%-1.42%
2026-07-28MTFLEANING RISK OFFLEANING_OFFFLAT+0.24%+0.23%
2026-07-28MGP_AM#ffab40CAUTIOUSFLAT+0.24%+0.23%
2026-07-27MTFLEANING RISK OFFLEANING_OFFFLAT+0.02%-0.78%
2026-07-27MGP_AM#ffab40CAUTIOUSFLAT+0.02%-0.78%
2026-07-26MTFLEANING RISK OFFLEANING_OFFNO_DATA--
2026-07-24MTFLEANING RISK OFFLEANING_OFFFLAT+0.10%+0.06%
2026-07-24MGP_AM#ffab40CAUTIOUSFLAT+0.10%+0.06%
2026-07-23MTFLEANING RISK OFFLEANING_OFFDOWN-1.23%-0.16%
2026-07-23MGP_AM#ffab40CAUTIOUSDOWN-1.23%-0.16%
2026-07-22MTFLEANING RISK OFFLEANING_OFFFLAT-0.12%+0.11%
2026-07-22MGP_AM#ffab40CAUTIOUSFLAT-0.12%+0.11%
2026-07-21MTFNEUTRALNEUTRALUP+0.83%+0.27%
2026-07-21MGP_AM#ffab40CAUTIOUSUP+0.83%+0.27%
2026-07-20MTFLEANING RISK OFFLEANING_OFFFLAT-0.16%-0.67%
2026-07-20MGP_AM#ffab40CAUTIOUSFLAT-0.16%-0.67%
2026-07-19MTFLEANING RISK OFFLEANING_OFFNO_DATA--
2026-07-18MTFLEANING RISK OFFLEANING_OFFNO_DATA--
2026-07-18MGP_AM#ffab40CAUTIOUSNO_DATA--
2026-07-17MTFLEANING RISK OFFLEANING_OFFDOWN-0.99%+0.16%
2026-07-17MGP_AM#ffab40CAUTIOUSDOWN-0.99%+0.16%
2026-07-16MTFLEANING RISK OFFLEANING_OFFDOWN-0.54%-0.27%
2026-07-16MGP_AM#00c853BULLISHDOWN-0.54%-0.27%
2026-07-15MTFNEUTRALNEUTRALUP+0.40%+0.08%
2026-07-15MGP_AM#ffab40CAUTIOUSUP+0.40%+0.08%
2026-07-14MTFRISK OFFRISK_OFFUP+0.36%+0.12%
2026-07-14MGP_AM#ffab40CAUTIOUSUP+0.36%+0.12%
2026-07-13MTFRISK OFFRISK_OFFDOWN-0.77%-0.44%
2026-07-13MGP_AM#00c853BULLISHDOWN-0.77%-0.44%
2026-07-10MTFLEANING RISK OFFLEANING_OFFUP+0.43%+0.39%
2026-07-10MGP_AM#ffab40CAUTIOUSUP+0.43%+0.39%
2026-07-09MTFLEANING RISK OFFLEANING_OFFUP+0.85%+0.58%
2026-07-09MGP_AM#ffab40CAUTIOUSUP+0.85%+0.58%
2026-07-08MTFRISK OFFRISK_OFFDOWN-0.31%+0.30%
2026-07-08MGP_AM#ffab40CAUTIOUSDOWN-0.31%+0.30%
2026-07-07MTFLEANING RISK OFFLEANING_OFFDOWN-0.48%-0.33%
2026-07-07MGP_AM#00c853BULLISHDOWN-0.48%-0.33%
2026-07-06MTFLEANING RISK OFFLEANING_OFFUP+0.87%+0.34%
2026-07-06MGP_AM#ffab40CAUTIOUSUP+0.87%+0.34%
2026-07-05MTFLEANING RISK OFFLEANING_OFFNO_DATA--
2026-07-05MGP_AM#ffab40CAUTIOUSNO_DATA--
2026-07-04MTFLEANING RISK OFFLEANING_OFFNO_DATA--
2026-07-03MTFLEANING RISK OFFLEANING_OFFNO_DATA--
2026-07-02MTFNEUTRALNEUTRALFLAT-0.13%-0.35%
2026-07-02MGP_AM#00c853BULLISHFLAT-0.13%-0.35%
2026-07-01MTFLEANING RISK OFFLEANING_OFFFLAT-0.14%+0.10%
2026-07-01MGP_AM#00c853BULLISHFLAT-0.14%+0.10%
2026-06-30MTFLEANING RISK ONLEANING_ONUP+0.78%+0.74%
2026-06-30MGP_AM#ffab40CAUTIOUSUP+0.78%+0.74%
2026-06-29MTFNEUTRALNEUTRALUP+1.65%+0.61%
2026-06-29MGP_AM#ffab40CAUTIOUSUP+1.65%+0.61%
2026-06-26MTFLEANING RISK OFFLEANING_OFFDOWN-0.72%+0.01%
2026-06-26MGP_AM#ffab40CAUTIOUSDOWN-0.72%+0.01%
2026-06-25MTFNEUTRALNEUTRALFLAT+0.14%-0.62%
2026-06-25MGP_AM#ffab40CAUTIOUSFLAT+0.14%-0.62%
2026-06-24MTFNEUTRALNEUTRALFLAT-0.05%-0.26%
2026-06-24MGP_AM#ffab40CAUTIOUSFLAT-0.05%-0.26%
2026-06-23MTFLEANING RISK OFFLEANING_OFFDOWN-1.45%-0.03%
2026-06-23MGP_AM#ffab40CAUTIOUSDOWN-1.45%-0.03%
2026-06-22MTFNEUTRALNEUTRALDOWN-0.31%-0.44%
2026-06-22MGP_AM#ffab40CAUTIOUSDOWN-0.31%-0.44%
2026-06-19MTFNEUTRALNEUTRALNO_DATA--
2026-06-18MTFNEUTRALNEUTRALUP+0.78%-0.14%
2026-06-18MGP_AM#00c853BULLISHUP+0.78%-0.14%
2026-06-17MTFUNKNOWNDOWN-1.25%-1.37%
2026-06-17MGP_AM#00c853BULLISHDOWN-1.25%-1.37%
2026-06-16MTFUNKNOWNDOWN-0.60%-0.56%
2026-06-16MGP_AM#00c853BULLISHDOWN-0.60%-0.56%
2026-06-15MTFUNKNOWNUP+1.76%+0.40%
2026-06-15MGP_AM#00c853BULLISHUP+1.76%+0.40%
2026-06-12MTFUNKNOWNUP+0.54%+0.14%
2026-06-12MGP_AM#00c853BULLISHUP+0.54%+0.14%
2026-06-11MGP_AM#ffab40CAUTIOUSUP+1.70%+1.23%
2026-06-10MGP_AM#ffab40CAUTIOUSDOWN-1.58%-1.09%
2026-06-09MGP_AM#00c853BULLISHFLAT-0.29%-0.88%
2026-06-08MGP_AM#ffab40CAUTIOUSFLAT+0.23%-0.56%
2026-06-05MGP_AM#ffab40CAUTIOUSDOWN-2.58%-1.96%
2026-06-04MGP_AM#ffab40CAUTIOUSUP+0.38%+0.66%
2026-06-03MGP_AM#ffab40CAUTIOUSDOWN-0.70%-0.52%
2026-06-02MGP_AM#ffab40CAUTIOUSFLAT+0.14%+0.34%
2026-06-01MGP_AM#00c853BULLISHFLAT+0.27%+0.42%
2026-05-29MGP_AM#00c853BULLISHFLAT+0.25%+0.08%
2026-05-28MGP_AM#ffab40CAUTIOUSUP+0.55%+0.58%
2026-05-27MGP_AM#00c853BULLISHFLAT-0.02%-0.06%
2026-05-26MGP_AM#00c853BULLISHUP+0.66%+0.08%
2026-05-22MGP_AM#ffab40CAUTIOUSUP+0.39%-0.08%
2026-05-21MGP_AM#ffab40CAUTIOUSFLAT+0.20%+0.55%
2026-05-20MGP_AM#ffab40CAUTIOUSUP+1.02%+0.75%
2026-05-19MGP_AM#ffab40CAUTIOUSDOWN-0.67%-0.14%
2026-05-18MGP_AM#ffab40CAUTIOUSFLAT-0.07%-0.16%
2026-05-15MGP_AM#ffab40CAUTIOUSDOWN-1.20%-0.35%