8 variants of the exit rule — swing pure, day-trade pure, time-based splits, and doc's 80/20 at 1R target. Same 580 trades, $1k risk, S&P 1500 · 5 years.
Winner (best Return/Drawdown): 1. Swing pure (baseline, hold 5d)
Trades
580
Net $ (5 yrs)
$+35,293
Max DD
$32,771
Return/DD
108%
Win rate
43.1%
Avg R
+0.17R
Sharpe (annualized)
0.53
All 8 strategies ranked by Return/Drawdown
Strategy
n
Net $
Δ vs baseline
Max DD
Δ DD
Win%
Avg R
Sharpe
Return/DD
1. Swing pure (baseline, hold 5d)
580
$+35,293
$+0
$32,771
$+0
43.1%
+0.17R
0.53
108%
5. 20/80 time (20% day 1, 80% day 5)
580
$+28,164
$-7,128
$27,213
$-5,558
43.8%
+0.14R
0.52
103%
3. 50/50 time (half day 1, half day 5)
580
$+17,661
$-17,632
$19,298
$-13,473
44.5%
+0.10R
0.50
92%
8. 50/50 at 1R + BE stop on runner
580
$+19,878
$-15,415
$30,689
$-2,082
50.7%
+0.05R
0.38
65%
4. 80/20 time (80% day 1, 20% day 5)
580
$+7,028
$-28,265
$12,474
$-20,297
46.2%
+0.06R
0.43
56%
6. Doc 80/20 at 1R target
580
$+10,421
$-24,872
$33,482
$+711
50.7%
+0.04R
0.30
31%
7. Doc 80/20 at 1R + BE stop on runner
580
$+10,459
$-24,834
$34,626
$+1,855
50.7%
+0.03R
0.22
30%
2. Day-trade pure (all out day 1 close)
580
$-51
$-35,344
$12,379
$-20,392
46.0%
+0.04R
0.31
-0%
Equity curves — top 4 strategies
1. Swing pure (baseline, hold 5d) 5. 20/80 time (20% day 1, 80% day 5) 3. 50/50 time (half day 1, half day 5) 8. 50/50 at 1R + BE stop on runner
Watch the divergence in the 2024 drawdown region — strategies that lock partial profit early recover faster.
How each strategy works
1. Swing pure — enter, hold all through day 5 close (or stop). Doc baseline.
2. Day-trade pure — enter, exit all at day 1 close (or intraday stop).
3. 50/50 time — half out at day 1 close, half runs to day 5. Time-based, no target.
4. 80/20 time — 80% at day 1 close, 20% runs. Locks most profit early.
5. 20/80 time — 20% at day 1 close (small trim), 80% runs. Mostly swing.
6. Doc 80/20 at 1R — sell 80% when price hits +1R above entry, 20% runs. Doc's rule.
7. Doc 80/20 at 1R + BE stop — same but stop moves to breakeven on the runner (protects against giveback).
8. 50/50 at 1R + BE — half at 1R, half runs with breakeven stop.