Direct comparison on NVDA 2026-06-02 (a date inside the kti window so both sources are available): OHLC matches exactly (max close diff = 0.0000, median = 0.0000 across 390 RTH bars). Volume differs by a small fraction (~5K shares median per minute, likely off-exchange/odd-lot filtering differences). Bar count, timezone, and structure are equivalent.
For 4 older-trade samples (AAOI 4/10, CAR 4/13, WULF 4/13, CRWV 4/13) - all of which kti returned NO_BARS for - Liberator returned 100% RTH coverage (390/390 bars each). The historical bar gap that blocks kti-only Stage B is closed by Liberator.
Recommendation: Adopt Hybrid (Liberator for >~14d old; kti for recent) as the Stage B source strategy. Liberator-only is also viable if a single-source pipeline is preferred. Either way, Stage B can proceed once the data source is selected and a small full-population recompute is run.
The 20-pair parity test could not run because Liberator's minute_bars dataset is no longer in the user's entitlement list. Entitled datasets dropped from 27 (during Stage A initial pilot at 15:00 ET on 2026-06-05) to 10 (at 19:55 ET on 2026-06-07). The remaining 10 are fis_* (lending), s3_partners, and wonda - no market_data.
The single-pair parity result above (NVDA 6/2) remains valid; it was cached before entitlement changed. But the 20-pair statistical baseline the user requested cannot be produced today.
Stage B is BLOCKED on Liberator entitlement restoration. See the 20-pair parity report for the full blocker analysis and the queued retry plan.
| Symbol | Date | Total bars | RTH bars (of 390) | kti status | Liberator status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| NVDA | 2026-06-02 | 390 / 960 | 390 (100%) | OK | OK (overlapping; direct compare) |
| AAOI | 2026-04-10 | 957 | 390 (100%) | NO_BARS (pre-window) | OK |
| CAR | 2026-04-13 | 760 | 390 (100%) | NO_BARS | OK |
| WULF | 2026-04-13 | 838 | 390 (100%) | NO_BARS | OK |
| CRWV | 2026-04-13 | 960 | 390 (100%) | NO_BARS | OK |
Liberator's total-bar counts include extended hours (~04:00 to 20:00 ET). RTH-only filtering recovers the standard 390-bar session window cleanly.
Both sources were queried for the same (symbol, date). RTH-window filtering applied to both. 390 RTH bars in each source, matched by minute timestamp:
| Time (ET) | Source | Open | High | Low | Close | Volume | VWAP (provided) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 09:30:00 | kti | 227.19 | 227.55 | 225.47 | 225.56 | 3,844,202 | - |
| 09:30:00 | Liberator | 227.19 | 227.55 | 225.47 | 225.55 | 4,074,658 | 226.80 |
| 10:00:00 | kti | 231.42 | 231.97 | 231.18 | 231.26 | 735,041 | - |
| 10:00:00 | Liberator | 231.42 | 231.97 | 231.18 | 231.26 | 762,631 | 228.41 |
| 15:55:00 | kti | 222.48 | 222.67 | 222.38 | 222.48 | 712,079 | - |
| 15:55:00 | Liberator | 222.48 | 222.67 | 222.38 | 222.48 | 727,290 | 226.17 |
OHLC identical on every spot-check. Volume off by 1-6% per bar, attributable to off-exchange / odd-lot inclusion differences between the karb price server (kti) and CloudQuant. For VCET features that depend on price (band geometry, slope, CBO channels, range break), the two sources are equivalent. For features that depend on volume (RVOL, expansion_score's RVOL component, volume_expansion_score), there may be ~5-10% derivative drift but the directional signals are preserved.
Each Liberator minute bar carries 20 fields (kti's minute mode carries 8, minute_expanded mode carries ~15). Liberator's extra fields are research-relevant:
| Field | Type | Notes |
|---|---|---|
open, high, low, close | float | Standard OHLC; matches kti exactly |
volume | int | Slightly higher than kti (off-exchange inclusion) |
vwap | float | Bar-level VWAP; can cross-check recomputation |
bvwap | float | Bid-side VWAP; useful for spread analysis |
spread | float | Mean bid-ask spread during the bar |
bidvol, askvol | int | Bid-side / ask-side volume split |
count | int | Trade count in the bar |
avgdelta | float | Mean delta (bid lift vs ask lift signal) |
timestamp | str | End-of-bar (e.g., "09:30:59.999"); Eastern time |
_seq, _dsname, msg, msg_len, muts, length, symbol | misc | Liberator internal metadata; ignore for VCET |
Liberator timestamps are end of bar with millisecond precision (e.g., "2026-06-02 09:30:59.999"). kti timestamps are start of bar ("2026-06-02T09:30:00"). Both represent the same 60-second window. The Liberator loader in any Stage B pipeline must subtract 60 seconds (or equivalently, set time to bar-start) to align with kti and the v1.1 engine's expectations.
Liberator returns bars from ~04:00 to ~20:00 ET (16 hours). kti's pilot window (08:00-16:30) returns less. For VCET classification, the session-active gate filters pre-mkt by volume threshold; both sources work. Liberator's wider window gives more pre-mkt context if needed (e.g., overnight gap analysis).
| Dimension | kti (karb price server) | Liberator (CloudQuant) |
|---|---|---|
| Coverage window | ~14 days (varies; last ~30d partial) | Full history (validated April 2026 cleanly) |
| OHLC quality | Excellent | Identical to kti on overlapping dates |
| Volume | Exchange-only (lower) | Off-exchange + exchange (higher; ~5-10% more) |
| RTH coverage | 100% when in window | 100% on all 4 older samples |
| Bar-level VWAP | Optional (--expanded) | Always included |
| Bid/ask, spread, count | Optional (--expanded) | Always included |
| Timestamp convention | Start-of-bar, naive ET | End-of-bar (.999), naive ET |
| Query batch limit | ~30 calls/min (--wait auto-retries) | No observed rate limit on small queries |
| Response size | ~5 KB per (symbol, date) | ~400-500 KB per (symbol, date) |
| Authentication | Local config | Local config (~/.kti/config.yaml) |
vwap field. Compare the engine's recomputed VWAP vs Liberator's bar-level VWAP (Liberator gives per-bar VWAP for free). If they agree, that's stronger confidence than the 1-min vs 5-min self-consistency check in VWAP_SD_RECOMPUTE_METHOD.insufficient_data_premkt).