J3P Backtest - Edge Read Market universe (SPY/QQQ/IWM + mega-caps)

James Three Plays (Pull-In / Trend / Backside) - 10 trading days ending 2026-06-26 - 5-min bars - generated 2026-06-27 ET
Trades171 Total P&L (per $100 risk/trade)$-3,539 Win %44.4% Avg R-0.208

Verdict - where the edge is (and isn't)

Edge gate (Stage 4 hotkeys): only positive-expectancy cells (avg_R>0, adequate n) advance. Charts of every trade: execution charts →

By Playbook

playbooknwinstotal_pnlavg_Ravg_mfe_Ravg_mae_Rwin_pct
vwap_pull_in13662$-1,948.40-0.144+0.475-0.62545.6%
trend_trade3414$-1,486.91-0.442+0.614-0.89641.2%
backside_scalp10$-103.94-1.035+0.531-1.2300.0%

By Playbook x Grade

playbookgradenwinstotal_pnlavg_Ravg_mfe_Ravg_mae_Rwin_pct
vwap_pull_inA11$25.15+0.254+0.392-0.890100.0%
vwap_pull_inB11$9.30+0.093+0.741-0.271100.0%
vwap_pull_in-13159$-1,816.92-0.140+0.475-0.62245.0%
trend_tradeB42$-72.78-0.184+0.273-0.72650.0%
trend_tradeC2912$-1,314.99-0.458+0.682-0.89241.4%
vwap_pull_inC31$-165.93-0.549+0.398-0.80533.3%
trend_tradeA10$-99.14-1.019+0.000-1.6970.0%
backside_scalpB10$-103.94-1.035+0.531-1.2300.0%

By Playbook x VCET Regime (the conditioning that matters)

playbookvcet_statenwinstotal_pnlavg_Ravg_mfe_Ravg_mae_Rwin_pct
vwap_pull_inCOMPRESSION11$22.28+0.224+0.394-0.044100.0%
vwap_pull_inMEAN_REVERSION21$-17.33-0.085+0.178-0.58250.0%
vwap_pull_inTREND_DOWN136$-160.78-0.118+0.650-0.57046.2%
vwap_pull_inROTATION10650$-1,456.70-0.138+0.452-0.63547.2%
vwap_pull_inTREND_UP144$-335.87-0.245+0.535-0.65028.6%
trend_tradeTREND_UP3414$-1,486.91-0.442+0.614-0.89641.2%
backside_scalpROTATION10$-103.94-1.035+0.531-1.2300.0%

By Playbook x Tier

playbooktiernwinstotal_pnlavg_Ravg_mfe_Ravg_mae_Rwin_pct
vwap_pull_inband2169$58.78+0.036+0.602-0.47856.2%
vwap_pull_inband34725$-359.91-0.076+0.567-0.70153.2%
vwap_pull_inband17328$-1,647.27-0.227+0.388-0.60938.4%
trend_trade1st_dev3414$-1,486.91-0.442+0.614-0.89641.2%
backside_scalpext10$-103.94-1.035+0.531-1.2300.0%

Full edge gate - Playbook x Grade x Tier x Regime

playbookgradetiervcet_statenwinstotal_pnlavg_Ravg_mfe_Ravg_mae_Rwin_pct
vwap_pull_in-band2TREND_DOWN33$178.54+0.603+1.170-0.220100.0%
vwap_pull_inAband3ROTATION11$25.15+0.254+0.392-0.890100.0%
vwap_pull_in-band1COMPRESSION11$22.28+0.224+0.394-0.044100.0%
vwap_pull_inBband2ROTATION11$9.30+0.093+0.741-0.271100.0%
vwap_pull_in-band3TREND_UP41$-13.87-0.034+0.314-0.48325.0%
vwap_pull_in-band2ROTATION94$-47.79-0.056+0.496-0.51744.4%
vwap_pull_in-band1MEAN_REVERSION21$-17.33-0.085+0.178-0.58250.0%
vwap_pull_in-band3ROTATION4223$-371.19-0.088+0.595-0.71754.8%
trend_tradeB1st_devTREND_UP42$-72.78-0.184+0.273-0.72650.0%
vwap_pull_in-band1ROTATION5120$-1,010.22-0.200+0.321-0.59239.2%
vwap_pull_in-band1TREND_UP62$-136.75-0.239+0.844-0.65333.3%
vwap_pull_in-band2TREND_UP31$-81.27-0.274+0.307-0.68533.3%
vwap_pull_inCband1ROTATION21$-61.95-0.306+0.475-0.61450.0%
vwap_pull_in-band1TREND_DOWN103$-339.32-0.334+0.494-0.67430.0%
trend_tradeC1st_devTREND_UP2912$-1,314.99-0.458+0.682-0.89241.4%
trend_tradeA1st_devTREND_UP10$-99.14-1.019+0.000-1.6970.0%
backside_scalpBextROTATION10$-103.94-1.035+0.531-1.2300.0%
vwap_pull_inCband1TREND_UP10$-103.98-1.035+0.245-1.1890.0%

Method & caveats

Symbols: AAPL, AMD, AMZN, AVGO, COIN, GOOGL, IWM, META, MSFT, MSTR, MU, NFLX, NVDA, PLTR, QQQ, SMCI, SPY, TSLA. Bars: real 1-min karb/kti -> 5-min. Regime: VCET v1.1 engine (vcet_state) per session. Plays mirror J3P_v2.2_SIP_Webhook.pine. Next-bar-open fills, conservative slippage, 0.5c/sh commission, constant $100 risk/trade sizing (so names of any price are comparable; total P&L = "if you risked $100/trade"). R = net P&L / initial risk. RTH 09:30-15:55 ET, force-flat 15:45. Single-digit-n cells are directional only. Roadmap: plan.