What the trade is. A stock has been rising for a while. It pauses and drifts back down to one of the average-price lines traders watch. It goes quiet there for a few days. Then it closes back above the fastest of those lines — and that is the signal to buy. We expect it to travel back up to the high it made before the pause.
How we checked it. We wrote the rules down precisely and had a computer apply them to 150 large US stocks over four years — about 4,100 trades. Crucially, we chose the rules using only the first two years, then scored them on the last two years the rules had never seen. A method that only works on the data used to invent it fails that test immediately. This one did not.
What we found. The trade itself works. But the money is made or lost after you are already in, and the exit rules the desk had written down were giving back about half the available profit. Different exit rules — same stocks bought, same money risked — roughly double the result. Nothing about the buying changes.
What the numbers mean. Results are quoted in “R”, which simply means “multiples of what you risked”. Risk any amount and make that same amount back and that is +1R. Our result is +0.39R — so the average trade returns about 39 cents for every dollar put at risk, after commission and spread. Real, but not enormous.
The catch worth knowing. More than half of these trades lose money. The profit comes from a minority that run a long way. That has a practical consequence: traders cannot pick and choose, because skipping the one trade that becomes the big winner removes the month's profit. A run of six or eight losses in a row is normal here, not a warning sign.
A trading pattern the desk already runs was formalised into written rules and tested across 4,528 trades over four years. The pattern shows a real, statistically durable edge — and the desk is currently capturing roughly half of it, because the exit rules were never written down.
Fixing the exit rules is a documentation and discipline change, not a new strategy. It requires no new technology, no new capital, and no new risk.
| Exit method | Net per tradePer trade, netWhat it isThe average profit per trade after subtracting commission and spread, expressed in R.What it tells youWhether the strategy makes money once real-world trading costs are paid. Gross figures flatter every strategy; this is the one that counts.How it is usedThe single headline number. Multiply by expected trade count to project a period.Our number+0.39R. The average trade returns 39% of what it risked. Costs consume 44% of the gross result, which is normal for a strategy with three exit points.Good — solid, not spectacular | Status |
|---|---|---|
| What the desk did on CRWD (no written rule) | +2.00R on a 10.63R moveThe CRWD tradeWhat it isA live trade the desk took on 31 July 2026, used here as the worked example.What it tells youIt shows the cost of the missing rule concretely rather than in the abstract.How it is usedThe trade is documented in full in the linked closeout review.Our numberThe move was worth 10.63R; the desk banked 2.00R. The difference was a hold rule that had never been written down.The problem, illustrated | Ad hoc |
| Current written ladder | +0.216R | In the checklist today |
| Best tested ladder | +0.389R | Recommended |
RR (risk unit)What it isThe amount of money put at risk on a single trade — the distance between the entry price and the price at which the trade is abandoned.What it tells youIt converts every trade to a common scale. A $200 stock and a $20 stock both risk 1R, so results can be averaged without one stock dominating.How it is usedAll results on this page are quoted in R. Multiply by whatever is risked per trade to get money: +0.39R returns 39 cents per dollar risked.Our numberMedian risk per trade in the study was 0.99% of the share price.Unit of measure is the risk unit — one R is the money risked per trade. A result of +0.39R means the average trade returns 39% of what it risked — 39 cents for every dollar. The rules currently written down return about 22 cents per dollar. These figures are net of estimated commission and spread, and exclude setups whose stop is too tight to be tradeable.
Trading costs are not a rounding error here — they consume between 41% and 67% of the gross result depending on the exit rules used. This is the single strongest argument for the recommended ladder, separate from its higher return.
| Exit ladder | Gross | Cost | Net | Cost as % of gross | Break-even cost |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Current checklist ladder | +0.519 | −0.304 | +0.216 | 58% | 0.257% |
| Trail the 30%, 5-DMA runner | +0.598 | −0.304 | +0.294 | 51% | 0.296% |
| Recommended — 17-DMA runner | +0.692 | −0.304 | +0.389 | 44% | 0.342% |
| Slowest runner — 50-DMA | +0.736 | −0.304 | +0.432 | 41% | 0.364% |
| Two tranches only | +0.450 | −0.304 | +0.147 | 67% | 0.222% |
Break-even cost is the round-trip cost at which that ladder returns exactly zero. Our assumption is 0.15%; the recommended ladder keeps working up to 0.34%, more than twice our estimate. The current checklist ladder breaks at 0.26%.
Net return per trade at different round-trip costs. Read across the row to see how much execution quality matters.
| Exit ladder | 0.05% | 0.10% | 0.15% assumed |
0.20% | 0.30% |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Current checklist ladder | +0.418 | +0.317 | +0.216 | +0.115 | −0.088 |
| Trail the 30%, 5-DMA runner | +0.497 | +0.396 | +0.294 | +0.193 | −0.009 |
| Recommended — 17-DMA runner | +0.591 | +0.490 | +0.389 | +0.288 | +0.085 |
| Slowest runner — 50-DMA | +0.634 | +0.533 | +0.432 | +0.331 | +0.129 |
| Two tranches only | +0.349 | +0.248 | +0.147 | +0.045 | −0.157 |
Every backtest rests on assumptions. These are ours, with an honest note on whether each one flatters the result optimistic, understates it conservative, or is unlikely to matter neutral.
| Commission + spread | 0.15% round trip, charged twice per trade because the ladder exits in three pieces. At the median stop of 0.99% of price that is 0.304R deducted from every trade — the difference between the +0.69R gross and +0.39R net figures. | Neutral |
| Stop slippage | None. Stops are assumed to fill at exactly the stop price. In reality stops gap through, especially on the news days that cause them. | Optimistic |
| Entry fills | At the closing price of the trigger bar, in full, with no market impact and no partial fills. | Optimistic |
| Overnight financing | Not modelled. Positions are held for days to weeks; borrow and margin costs are real but small relative to 0.15%. | Slightly optimistic |
| Stocks | 150 US common stocks, ranked by dollar volume on 30 Dec 2022 with a $10 minimum price, then frozen — never re-ranked. No stock was chosen because it later did well. | Neutral |
| Period | October 2022 – August 2026. Rules chosen on Oct 2022 – Dec 2024; results quoted from Jan 2025 – Aug 2026 only. | Neutral |
| Bars | 30-minute bars, regular hours only (09:30–16:00 ET). Pre-market and after-hours activity is invisible to the test. | Neutral |
| Market regime | The window is essentially one large-cap bull market. There is no bear-market segment of any length in the sample. | Optimistic |
| Company size | Large caps only. The desk also trades small caps, which gap more and carry wider spreads. | Optimistic |
| Stop placement | The lowest low of the trigger bar and the two bars before it. | Neutral |
| Minimum stop | Setups with a stop tighter than 0.25% of the share price are discarded entirely — 7% of all setups. They are not executable, but discarding rather than widening the stop throws away trades that could have been taken with more risk. | Conservative |
| Maximum stop | Setups risking more than 25% of the share price are discarded. | Neutral |
| Maximum hold | 60 trading days, after which the position is marked at the last close rather than sold. A mark is not a fill. | Slightly optimistic |
| Position sizing | Every trade is weighted equally, as if the same dollar risk were taken each time. No limit on how many positions run at once. | Optimistic |
| Included | Price above a rising 50-day average; a close back above the 5-day average after being below it; and a pullback that touched the 10, 20 or 50-day average within the prior eight sessions. | Neutral |
| Not included | The desk's actual qualification filters. Bollinger-width percentile, coil bar count, volume pocket and moving-average cluster width are all absent. The tested filter is looser than the one traders use, so it admits setups the desk would reject. | Unknown direction |
| Entry trigger | A break of the prior day's high. The desk's CRWD trade was entered on a VWAP pull-in instead — a related but different trigger. Resolving which is canonical is the top open item on this project. | Unknown direction |
| Excluded | Taxes; trading halts; order rejections; capital or buying-power limits; earnings gaps treated as ordinary bars; and any discretionary decision a trader would make in the moment. | Optimistic |
Adopt the tested exit rules now and trade the play at reduced size while the remaining tests complete. The exit change is worth roughly +80% per trade against the rules currently written down, and that conclusion is unaffected by the correction above — both figures moved together. The exit change is low-risk — it alters how existing positions are managed, not what is bought or how much is risked — and it is the difference between capturing half the edge and most of it.
Do not increase size or capital allocation until the entry question is resolved and the failed-setup data is in hand. The statistics are strong; the coverage is not yet wide enough to justify scaling.
The same text appears as a pop-up wherever a term is used on this page. Hover it, or tap it on a phone.